All-American Restaurant
With Italian Roots
Where Big Flavor
Meets a Big Heart
Step into Sonny D’s, where each dish is crafted with the kind of care you’d expect from family—because that’s exactly how we see our guests. With over 40 years in the restaurant business starting in Chicago, we are proud to continue the tradition of creating a space for memories and flavors now in New Buffalo, Michigan.
OUR MENU
Our menu is a love letter to American classics catering to every palette. Think burgers that require two hands, fresh-caught seafood that tastes like a coastal vacation, and yes, a nod to our Italian roots with signature recipes that have been passed down and perfected for generations.
EXPERIENCES
Sonny D’s is about experiences. From our Speakeasy downstairs (with entertainment nearly every night) to the oversized portions that’ll have you reaching for a to-go box, every visit is a story waiting to happen.
Since 1995
Our History
How it all started
Born Santo Damico in 1935, Sonny D was a vibrant and altruistic individual deeply rooted in Chicago's South Side. His charismatic personality, love for family, and joy in sharing home-cooked meals defined him. He dedicated his life to peddling fresh produce around his local community.
Sonny's Speakeasy
Tucked beneath Sonny D’s, our Speakeasy is where the fun truly begins. Step into a space that blends vintage 1920s prohibition vibes with a lively modern twist. Whether you’re here to sip on bespoke cocktails, enjoy a cold draft beer, or immerse yourself in the vibrant energy of our events, there’s always something happening downstairs.
From live performances by local talent to spirited trivia nights, crowd-pleasing karaoke, and even surprise pop-ups, every evening in the Speakeasy promises something new. Doors open at 5pm—so come ready to mix, mingle, and make some memories.
Sonny's Inner Circle
Loyalty Program
Start Earning Rewards by Joining Our Loyalty Program.
• Earn 1 point for every $1 spent.
• Earn $5 for every 50 points.
• 25 Bonus Points upon sign-up.
• Double Points on Monday.
To begin, fill out the form below to sign up below.
Sonny's Speakeasy
Join us on the lower level of Sonny D’s for bespoke cocktails, live music, and karaoke!
Rainbow Cone
Craving something sweet? Visit our Original Rainbow Cone location behind Sonny D’s!
Sunday Night Trivia | Theme: Water & Modern Country
Sunday Trivia Nights at Sonny D's
🗓️ EVERY Sunday (unless stated otherwise)
⏰ Time: 6:00 PM
📍 Where: Sonny D’s Speakeasy, New Buffalo, MI
HOW IT WORKS:
3 Trivia Categories (with different themes each week).
10 questions per round.
1. General Trivia - (⭐THEME: General)
2. Music Trivia – (⭐THEME: Modern Country)
3. Wildcard Trivia – (⭐THEME: Water)
PRIZES:
🏆 1st Place – $100 Sonny D’s Gift Card
🥈 2nd Place – $75 Sonny D’s Gift Card
🥉 3rd Place – Pick next week’s Wildcard category!
🏅PARTICIPATION PRIZE: Last Place? No problem! You get a “Just Happy to Play” gift card, which means $20 towards your next Trivia Night!... See MoreSee Less
Watch Party: Lion vs Cowboys
Date & Time:
Saturday, December 4th, 2025
Kick-off: 8:15 PM (Eastern)
FREE ENTRY
Location:
Sonny D's Speakeasy
Event Description:
Join us for the ultimate Game Watch Party at Sonny D's!
Don’t miss this perfect combination of game day vibes, great food, and incredible company!... See MoreSee Less
Luis Orosio - Live Music @ Sonny D's (Every Fri + Sat)
Live Music Performances:
🗓️ Every Friday + Saturday
⏰ Time: 7:00 PM - 10:00 PM EST
📍 Where: Sonny D’s Speakeasy, New Buffalo, MI
Anthony Massaro - Live Music @ Sonny D's (Every Fri & Sat)
Live Music Performances:
🗓️ Every Friday + Saturday
⏰ Time: 7:00 PM - 10:00 PM EST
📍 Where: Sonny D’s Speakeasy, New Buffalo, MI
Dueling Pianos at Sonny's Speakeasy
Dueling Pianos at Sonny D's!
Enjoy these must-see performers as they take over the Speakeasy stage once a month.
Come on out and request all your favorite songs🪩💃🏻... See MoreSee Less
Johnny V - Live Music @ Sonny D's (Every Fri + Sat)
Live Music Performances:
🗓️ Every Friday + Saturday
⏰ Time: 7:00 PM - 10:00 PM EST
📍 Where: Sonny D’s Speakeasy, New Buffalo, MI
Line Dancing Class with Sunset Coast Country Dancers
THIS EVENT IS A LINE-DANCING TUTORIAL CLASS HOSTED BY SUNSET COAST COUNTRY DANCERS!
Kick up your boots and join us for an unforgettable night of line-dancing at Sonny D’s Speakeasy! Whether you’re brand new or a seasoned two-stepper, our friends from Sunset Coast Country Dancers will walk (and dance) you through all the moves.
TIMELINE DETAILS:
Doors open at 5PM, instruction and dancing from 8PM–12AM.
✨ What to Expect:
Free Admission – just bring your party spirit!
Step-by-Step Instruction – perfect for beginners or anyone wanting to brush up on their skills.
Classic Country Vibes – boots, hats, and a speakeasy setting for the ultimate Western night.
Great Drinks & Good Company – enjoy craft cocktails from the Sonny D’s bar while you dance.
Fun for Groups or Singles – come with friends or meet new dance partners here!
No reservations needed—just show up ready to dance. Let’s turn Sonny D’s into the rowdiest (and friendliest) dance floor in town!... See MoreSee Less
Brunch with Santa (AND Feed a Reindeer)!
🎅 BRUNCH WITH SANTA + REINDEER EXPERIENCE AT SONNY D’S 🎅
📅 Saturday, December 20th
🕙 10 AM – 6 PM
📍 Sonny D’s (Downstairs, Outside & Upstairs)
This December, Sonny D’s is turning into the North Pole for one magical day of family fun, festive eats, and holiday cheer! Bring the whole crew and make a day of it — brunch, crafts, cocoa, and even a visit from the man in red himself.
🎄 DOWNSTAIRS ACTIVITIES:
🍪 Cookie Decorating Bar
❄️ Snowflake Crafting Station
✨ Letters to Santa + Storytime
📸 Holiday Photo Ops
🦌 OUTSIDE
🐾 Feed a Reindeer — meet one of Santa’s magical reindeer!
🍳 UPSTAIRS BRUNCH
Enjoy a festive holiday brunch menu for kids and grown-ups alike — think cozy comfort dishes, cocoa, and seasonal specials.
💝 DETAILS
ENTRY: $10 or a wrapped gift donation for local families
TIMELINE:
10 AM–2 PM → Reindeer visits
10 AM–3 PM → Santa meet & greets
Family-friendly fun continues until 6 PM — then we’ll switch gears for our evening live performer in the Speakeasy 🎶... See MoreSee Less
Jim Post - Live Music @ Sonny D's (Every Fri + Sat)
Live Music Performances:
🗓️ Every Friday + Saturday
⏰ Time: 7:00 PM - 10:00 PM EST
📍 Where: Sonny D’s Speakeasy, New Buffalo, MI
Aaron Wright - Live Music @ Sonny D's (Every Fri + Sat)
Live Music Performances:
🗓️ Every Friday + Saturday
⏰ Time: 7:00 PM - 10:00 PM EST
📍 Where: Sonny D’s Speakeasy, New Buffalo, MI
Watch Party: Bears vs 49ers
Date & Time:
Saturday, December 28th, 2025
Kick-off: 8:20 PM (Eastern)
FREE ENTRY
Location:
Sonny D's Speakeasy
Event Description:
Join us for the ultimate Game Watch Party at Sonny D's!
Don’t miss this perfect combination of game day vibes, great food, and incredible company!... See MoreSee Less
New Year's Eve in the Speakeasy
✨ SPEAKEASY NEW YEAR’S EVE PARTY ✨
📅 Tuesday, December 31st
🕒 8 PM – Late
📍 Sonny D’s Speakeasy
Free Admission
21+ to Enter
Overnight, the North Pole magic fades… and the Speakeasy transforms from Santa’s cozy hideout into a scene of pure glitz and glamour to ring in 2026 the right way.
Slip into something sparkling and step behind the curtain for an unforgettable night filled with:
🎧 Live DJ spinning all night long
🥂 Champagne toasts & signature cocktails
Whether you’re celebrating with your favorite people or flying solo into the new year, the Speakeasy is where the countdown comes alive.... See MoreSee Less